I have always been a little underwhelmed by the draft gear available to HO scale modelers, be they the "boxes" on simple cars or the "scale" draft gear available from various purveyors. I find them to be either too wide, with ridiculously large openings for the couplers and/or too undetailed. Byron Rose created patterns for very nicely detailed draft gear included in many Westerfield offerings, but it was wider than I preferred, no doubt to accommodate Kadee no. 5 couplers (scale-sized or close to scale couplers were still in the future when the patterns were created.)
I recently tested a half dozen cars equipped with the parts on a layout with numerous handlaid turnouts and radii down to about 20-22". The cars were mostly forty-footers, but did include the 50' X32A. I can report that there was not a single issue related to coupler swing and the only issues encountered were the same as with many other cars where the couplers did not couple on the first attempt. The cars were operated and switched for several hours, providing a good amount of feedback about how the draft gear would function, even with 50' cars around tight curves.
I have included this draft gear in several recent kit offerings and will now move to offer them as separate parts as soon as I can produce sufficient quantities to release them.




Ted,
ReplyDeleteI share your view on draft gear choices. I have recently been using Moloco's non-cushioned draft gear which are nice. Looking at Car Builder Cyclopedias, it's amazing how many variations were available. I have noticed in my own modeling that I have always placed the draft gear flush with car end or against the angled flange if cast in, which I have quickly realized is wrong, especially on wood sheathed cars as the box may extend up to 8-10" from the car end. I was also surprised at how many have a train line bracket mounting tab cast in with many cars having the trainline mounted to the pocket, not the car end. Attention to detail, for sure! I would like to see a couple of versions on the market and, just my two cents, with countersunk mounting holes, like Moloco has. Hint, hint. Keep it up, mister.
I confess that I hadn't given the screw much thought since the wheels largely hide them... but a little sleuthing and there are plenty of options! https://www.mcmaster.com/products/product-line~~screws-and-bolts~~2q3Rr7zj/thread-size~0-80/fastener-head-type~flat/
Delete